Plush Toys

Sort By:  
Blue - Multipet Lamb Chop w/ Birthday Hat Plush Dog Toy  - 10.5\
Blue - Multipet Lamb Chop w/ Birthday Hat Plush Dog Toy - 10.5" ('MU48747)
There's no better way to say "Happy Birthday" than with Lamb Chop(R)! Shari Lewis' classic and beloved lamb is adored by countless customers and their dogs. Its super soft exterior makes Lamb Chop(R) great for cuddling, playing, or in this case - partying! Available in two colors. Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$11.99  Inc Tax
goDog Dragon w/Chew Guard Coral Plush Dog Toy Large - Large
goDog Dragon w/Chew Guard Coral Plush Dog Toy Large - Large ('WWGD70638)

Whimsical, bright creatures which are as tough as they are cute. Made with super soft bubble plush fabric and lined with Chew Guard Technology(TM) these toys stand up to tough play. Minimal stuffing gives these toys a fun floppy feel that dogs love. Puncture-proof squeakers are added for endless fun!

Special Features:

  • Soft & Durable Plush: The goDog Dragons Skinny Squeaker Dog Toy is a cute and cuddly plush toy that features a classic playtime favorite - a built-in squeaker - for maximum fun that'll hold your puppy's attention for hours!
  • Built-In Squeaker: This durable dog toy has a built-in squeaker to entice and excite your dog, with double-stitched seams to ensure your dog's toy lasts through many games of fetch.
  • Perfect for Cuddling: With a fun, textured, bubble plush body, this adorable dog toy is made for hours of interactive and solo playtime fun. Plus, it's soft, comfortable and perfect for cuddling.
  • Designed to Last Longer: Our soft plush dog toys are made with Chew Guard Technology which is a special manufacturing process that adds a tough, heavy-duty, chew-resistant lining to our soft plush toys so that they're a little more durable(more...) Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$21.97  Inc Tax
Blue - Outward Hound Invincibles Snake Durable Plush Dog Toy  - XL
Blue - Outward Hound Invincibles Snake Durable Plush Dog Toy - XL ('OH32069)
Outward Hound's line of Invincibles was specifically designed for dogs who like to play rough. While still cuddly and cute on the outside, these plush toys have a special Dura-Tuff inner lining and double-layered outer seams to keep your pup's new best friends intact longer. The stuff-free design reduces messiness and multiple squeakers will keep your dog entertained even after they've bitten through. With options ranging from XS Invincible Minis to our XXL Invincible Snake, these tough plush toys were made for all dogs to sink their teeth into. Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$16.99  Inc Tax
KONG(R) Cozie(TM) Ali Alligator  - Small
KONG(R) Cozie(TM) Ali Alligator - Small ('KGZY3)
The KONG Cozie(TM) Ali Alligator is a soft and luxuriously cuddly plush toy great for snuggle time comfort. Made with an extra layer of material for added strength, the KONG Cozie(TM) Ali Alligator is an ideal toy for softer chew sessions and indoor fun. The KONG Cozie(TM) Ali Alligator toy is sure to delight during snuggle and play time!

Special Features
  • Deluxe push for indoor snuggle time
  • Extra layer of material for added strength
  • Squeaker entices active play
  • Ideal for indoor fun
  • Adorable characters add to the fun

Product Details:
Weight: 2 ounces
HxWxL: 2 x 5.5 x 7 inches Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$7.99  Inc Tax
ZippyPaws Spencer the Crinkle Monkey - Large Rainbow
ZippyPaws Spencer the Crinkle Monkey - Large Rainbow ('ZP1067)
Zippy Miniz are perfect for replacing critters in Zippy Burrows or even as fun little toys for small dogs. Comes in a pack of 3. Squeaker: 1 round squeaker inside each critter Package size: 6 x 4.5 x 2 in Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$12.99  Inc Tax
FuzzYard Dog Toy Kris Kringle L
FuzzYard Dog Toy Kris Kringle L ('FYDFZT1087)
Meet Kris Kringle, your dogs fuzzy festive friend. You're dogs sure to get up to some mischeif with this cheeky friend ;)

FuzzYard Christmas themed toys are super plush, addictive and designed locally in Australia at our FuzzYard toy factory by our team of creative Elves and part-time dog whisperers. Each toy has been fitted with a squeaker for added playtime enjoyment making FuzzYard toys the pawfect gift for your pup this Howli-day season!

Features and Benefits:
  • Designed in Australia
  • Machine washable
  • 100% polyester with an added internal squeaker.
  • Color-safe, non-toxic, and non-allergenic.


Materials: 100% polyester shell and polyester fibre filling with an added internal squeaker. Color-safe, non-toxic, and non-allergenic.
Care: Gentle machine wash with cold water and like colors. Do not bleach. Do not dry clean. Do not iron. Do not tumble dry.

Toy Dimensions:
Weight: 3.88 ounces

LxWxH 7.48 x 5.12 x 9.84 inches Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$14.99  Inc Tax
Multipet Swingin\' Flatties Plush Dog Toy Assorted Animals 27\
Multipet Swingin' Flatties Plush Dog Toy Assorted Animals 27" ('MU57345)

Long legs, a stuffing-free body, and a crinkle inside; these Swingin' Flatties are perfect for dogs who love a game of tug-o-war. Not only that but they squeak too!

Product Details:
Weight: 4.69 ounces
HxWxL: 27 x 4.5 x 6.25 inches

Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$13.05  Inc Tax
SnugArooz Nacho Business Plush Dog Toy 10\
SnugArooz Nacho Business Plush Dog Toy 10" ('SNG96384)
This toy is Nacho Business. We do not want to taco about it either. Toy contains crinkle and squeaker. Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$6.99  Inc Tax
ZippyPaws Miniz 3-Pack Donutz
ZippyPaws Miniz 3-Pack Donutz ('ZP896)
Zippy Miniz are perfect for replacing critters in Zippy Burrows or even as fun little toys for small dogs. Comes in a pack of 3. Squeaker: 1 round squeaker inside each critter Package size: 6 x 4.5 x 2 in Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$12.99  Inc Tax
goDog Furballz w/Chew Guard Rainbow Plush Dog Toy - Small
goDog Furballz w/Chew Guard Rainbow Plush Dog Toy - Small ('WWGD73736)
Features silly, googly eyes and bright, fun colors to attract a dog's attention. The round shape is ideal for tossing and retrieving. Features a big, loud ball-shaped squeaker that drive dogs crazy. Made with soft, fuzzy faux fur that dogs love and lined with Chew Guard Technology(TM), these toys stand up to tough play.

Special Features:
  • SOFT & DURABLE PLUSH: The goDog Furballz Soft Plush Ball Squeaker Dog Toys are cute, colorful, and cuddly plush toys with a built-in squeaker and super fluffy plush dogs love.
  • BUILT-IN SQUEAKER: This durable dog toy has a built-in squeaker to entice and excite your dog, with only one seam in the entire toy that is double-stitched to ensure your dog's toy lasts through many games of fetch and chase.
  • PERFECT FOR CUDDLING: This soft, plush-textured dog toy is the perfect cuddle buddy; it's great for pets that love to curl up and snuggle with stuffed toys
  • DESIGNED TO LAST LONGER: Our soft plush dog toys are made with Chew Guard Technology, which adds a tough, heavy-duty, chew-resistant lining to our soft plush toys, making them a little more durable than your average dog toy

Product Details:
Weight: 2 ounces
HxWxL: 4 x 4 x 4 inches Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$13.63  Inc Tax
PetShop by Fringe Studio Thorny But Cute Plush Dog Toy
PetShop by Fringe Studio Thorny But Cute Plush Dog Toy ('FRNG314156)
Prickly and sweet! Pet Shop by Fringe Studio "Thorny, but Cute" is perfect for playtime, anytime. Made with a super loud squeaker and stuffed with fluff, this toy was designed with interactive play in mind. Whether you squeak, toss, or tug it, your pup will be prinkled with fun. Great for all sized dogs and not intended for aggressive chewers.

Special Features:
  • Super loud squeaker
  • Crinkle paper
  • Great for fetch & play
  • Perfect for all-sized dogs
  • 11.5" h x 10" w x 4.5" d

Product Details:
Material: Plastic/Polyester
Dimensions: 11.5" x 10" Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$14.00  Inc Tax
goDog Amphibianz Gecko Squeaky Plush Dog Toy Large
goDog Amphibianz Gecko Squeaky Plush Dog Toy Large ('WWGD73041)

goDog Amphibianz are big, bright critters with a Squeaker and Chew Guard Technology for added durability. goDog plush dog toys are designed to be stronger and last longer. Made more durable with Chew Guard Technology a special manufacturing process that adds a super tough and durable lining to soft plush toys. goDog gives pet parents the best of all worlds: innovative products, stylish designs, environmental responsibility, and exceptional value with a variety of toys and beds to meet a dog's needs for play, retreat, rest, and fun! goDog products are designed to meet child safety standards and are backed by our 100% satisfaction guarantee. If a customer is dissatisfied with a goDog product for any reason, we will replace or refund it.

Disclaimer: While our toys are built to be tougher than standard plush toys, unfortunately no toy is indestructible, and some dogs can destroy the toys depending on their play and chew patterns.

Special Features:

  • SOFT & DURABLE PLUSH: The goDog Amphibianz Gecko Squeaker Dog Toy is a cute and cuddly plush toy that features a classic playtime favorite - a built-in squeaker - for maximum fun that'll hold your puppy's attention for hours!
  • BUILT-IN SQUEAKER: T(more...) Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$20.18  Inc Tax
KONG(R) Shakers(TM) Luvs Elephant Dog Plush Toy  - Large
KONG(R) Shakers(TM) Luvs Elephant Dog Plush Toy - Large ('KGSLV12)
KONG Shakers Luv's has a unique extended body with arms wide open for frolicking rounds of tug, toss and fetch. Its extended body is long on fun making it great for shaking and flopping while a low-toned squeaker sparks natural instincts and prolongs playtime.

Special Features
  • Extra-long body makes shaking more fun
  • Squeaker entices play
  • Shaped to fling; fetch and tug

Product Details:
Weight: 5.9 ounces
HxWxL: 18.5 x 7.5 x 9 inches Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$11.99  Inc Tax
Multipet Margaritaville(R) Mini Gumbo Shrimp Plush Dog Toy Assorted 6\
Multipet Margaritaville(R) Mini Gumbo Shrimp Plush Dog Toy Assorted 6" ('MU56353)

It's 5 O'Clock Somewhere...

It's in the tropics somewhere between the Port of Indecision and Southwest of Disorder, but no parallels of latitude or longitude mark the spot exactly. You don't have to be a navigator to get there. Palm trees provide the camouflage, ocean breezes bring the seaplanes and sailboats, tourists and travelers. Passports are not required. Island music rules. No waiting lines for anything.

There is a beach and a thatched roof bar perched on the edge of the turquoise sea where you can always find a bar stool. There are lots of lies and loads of stories. It's a comical concoction that blends together like tequila, salt, and lime.

Available in assorted colors - Squeaks!

Product Details:
Weight: 0.7 ounces
HxWxL: 5 x 3.5 x 2.5 inches

Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$6.00  Inc Tax
ZippyPaws Birthday Bandana and Bone 2-Pack
ZippyPaws Birthday Bandana and Bone 2-Pack ('ZP1600)

The perfect gift for your doggo's special day, the all-new Birthday Donutz toy features colorful embroidered confetti "sprinkles" and "frosting" that makes it look like a real delicious birthday donut! Each festive Birthday Donutz toy includes 2 ZippyPaws exclusive Crescent squeakers for all-around fun!

Product Materials: 5% EVA, 95% polyester
Toy Weight: 2.7 ounces
Toy Dimensions (HxWxL): 7 x 7 x 1.8 inches

Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$9.99  Inc Tax
Wagsdale Let\'s Be Frank 3pc Small Dog Toy Set
Wagsdale Let's Be Frank 3pc Small Dog Toy Set ('FRNG289509)
Welcome to Wagsdale! "Let's Be Frank" mini toy set is perfect for the pup that likes to play all day. Made with a loud squeaker in each toy and stuffed with fluff, your pup will scream Hot Dawg these toys are the pawfect. Great for small dogs and not intended for aggressive chewers.

Special Features:
  • 3 toys for 3 times the fun
  • Loud squeaker in each toy
  • Great for fetch and play
  • Perfect for small sized dogs

Product Material: Plastic/Polyester Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$12.00  Inc Tax
KONG(R) Shakers(TM) Honkers Turkey Dog Plush Toy Large
KONG(R) Shakers(TM) Honkers Turkey Dog Plush Toy Large ('KGSHK13)
KONG Shakers Honkers Turkey is a good-time gobbler whose internal neck features a texture that satisfies a dogs' natural chewing instincts while the long floppy legs spark shaking and tugging playtime fun. The low tone squawk and the reinforced plush design keep dogs interested and playing longer.

Special Features
  • Long plush toy ideal for tugging and shaking
  • Internal textured neck for natural chewing instincts
  • Floppiness and length ideal for fetching fun
  • Turkey character for added playtime fun
  • Low tone squeaker keeps dogs playing

Product Details:
Weight: 7.9 ounces
HxWxL: 7.5 x 9.75 x 16.5 inches Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$15.99  Inc Tax
goDog Just For Me Checkers Skinny Cow w/Chew Guard Plush Dog Toy
goDog Just For Me Checkers Skinny Cow w/Chew Guard Plush Dog Toy ('WWGD73556)
Made from a super soft, durable plush fabric with a checkered texture that dogs love! All Checkers plush toys are made with Chew Guard Technology(TM), include a fun squeaker, and are sized for all breeds to enjoy. All goDog plush toys are made with Chew Guard Technology(TM) which adds a super tough, durable liner making it strong enough to stand up to even the toughest play.

Special Features:
  • SOFT & DURABLE: goDog's Checkers are cute and cuddly squeaky toys made with soft, checkered-textured plush that dogs love to play and cuddle with; featuring reinforced seams and chew-resistant lining for fun, long-lasting solo and interactive play
  • BUILT-IN SQUEAKER: The dog toy is designed with a built-in squeaker to entice and excite your pup, satisfying their hunting instincts and chewing behavior to keep their interest during play
  • ENRICHMENT: The immediate auditory feedback of the Checkers plush toys excite dogs and encourages play; they are designed to provide enrichment and stimulation, catering to your dog's natural and instinctual behavior to keep them busy and entertained
  • PERFECT FOR CUDDLING: This soft, plush-textured dog toy is the perfect cuddle buddy; it's great for pets that love to curl up and snuggle with stuffed toys
    $9.57  Inc Tax
Outward Hound Invincibles Dog Durable Plush Dog Toy Orange XS
Outward Hound Invincibles Dog Durable Plush Dog Toy Orange XS ('OH32010)
Outward Hound's line of Invincibles was specifically designed for dogs who like to play rough. While still cuddly and cute on the outside, these plush toys have a special Dura-Tuff inner lining and double-layered outer seams to keep your pup's new best friends intact longer. The stuff-free design reduces messiness and multiple squeakers will keep your dog entertained even after they've bitten through. With options ranging from XS Invincible Minis to our XXL Invincible Snake, these tough plush toys were made for all dogs to sink their teeth into. Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$5.99  Inc Tax
FuzzYard Zoomie Energy Drink Plush Dog Toy
FuzzYard Zoomie Energy Drink Plush Dog Toy ('FYFZT1208)

Does your dog love the thrill of the chase? Go full speed with the FuzzYard Zoomie Energy Drink plush toy. FuzzYard super plush dog toys are fitted with a squeaker and crinkle paper for endless playtime fun and are loved by doggos across the globe.

When it comes to plush toys, no one does it quite like FuzzYard! These fun and original supaw plush toys are fitted with an attention-grabbing squeaker for the ulti-mutt playtime enjoyment. The internal crinkle paper makes these toys extra engaging for your furry friend. FuzzYard toys are famous and loved by dogs across the globe!

Special Features:

  • Attention grabbing internal squeaker
  • Internal crinkle paper for extra engagement
  • Machine washable
  • 100% polyester. Color-safe, non-toxic, and non-allergenic.


Product Details:
Material: Polyester
Weight: 2 ounces
HxWxL: 7.1 x 2.8 x 2.8 inches

Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$9.99  Inc Tax
KONG(R) SoftSeas Turtle Dog Plush Toy - Large ('KGRSF13)
KONG SoftSeas Turtle's thick plush makes it irresistible for grabbing while its long appendages send dogs into waves of shaking fun while satisfying natural thrashing instincts. Ideal for cuddling or gentle indoor play; it squeaks and crinkles, keeping pups submerged in long-lasting, healthy playtime fun.

Special Features
  • Unique plush shape ideal for shaking fun
  • Varied materials for multiple ways to play
  • Squeaks and crinkles extends playtime

Product Details:
Weight: 6.5 ounces
HxWxL: 3.75 x 14 x 11.5 inches Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$17.99  Inc Tax
ZippyPaws Halloween Miniz Flying Frights (3pack)
ZippyPaws Halloween Miniz Flying Frights (3pack) ('ZPC1812)

Zippy Miniz are perfect for replacing toys in Zippy Burrows or even as fun little toys for small dogs. This 3-pack includes a candy corn bat, a ghost and a bat!

Weight: 2.2 ounces

Dimensions, inches (L x W x H): 8.7 x 2 x 6

Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$12.99  Inc Tax
ZippyPaws Donutz Buddies - Choco
ZippyPaws Donutz Buddies - Choco ('ZPC1862)
Playtime is more fun with LINE FRIENDS! The adorable CHOCO from LINE FRIENDS has transformed into a super cute Donutz Buddies toy - and she is ready to play! CHOCO features an embroidered face and sprinkles, sewn on pink bow and ears, and an attached Line Friends tag.If you love our best-selling classic Donutz dog toys, you'll adore our LINE FRIENDS Donutz Buddies! Featuring the same ZippyPaws exclusive Crescent squeakers your dog craves, LINE FRIENDS Donutz Buddies are just like our classic Donutz, but reimagined as adorable LINE FRIENDS characters for maximum cuteness overload! No stuffing.
  • Squeaker: 2 Crescent squeakers
  • Toy size: 7.5 x 7 x 2 in
Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$9.99  Inc Tax
ZippyPaws Donutz Rainbow
ZippyPaws Donutz Rainbow ('ZP1021)
Chomp into fun with all-new Bottle Crusherz! They are just like our popular Happy Hour Crusherz, but wilder! The Bottle Crusherz Alligator is lined for durability and features a new and improved hook and loop closure, making it more difficult for your dog to remove the water bottle. Each Bottle Crusherz toy comes with a free water bottle and a *reusable squeaky cap so you can refill it with empty water bottles to keep your dog crunching for hours. *Reusable squeaky cap works with most water bottles (Arrowhead, Aquafina, Nestle).

Product Materials:
30% PET, 20% cotton, 50% polyester

Toy Dimensions:
Weight: 2.2 ounces
HxLxW: 11 x 3 x 3 inches Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$9.99  Inc Tax
BARK Whipped Pupkin Latte Plush Dog Toy
BARK Whipped Pupkin Latte Plush Dog Toy ('BRK212981)

This coffee drink dog toy is just what your pup ordered. This seasonal cold boo is packed with fluff, crazy crinkle, and a deep squeaker for dogs on the go. Sorry, no substitutions. Snap a pic of your furry influencer with their Pumpkin Spooks Latte to give their followers some foam FOMO.

From the creators of BarkBox, this BARK original toy is play-tested and dog-approved. Made by dog people, for dogs and their people, backed by BARK's Happiness Guarantee.

Caution: Keep away from children. Remove all packaging. If any piece of this toy becomes loose or detached, discard toy immediately. Never leave your dog unattended with any toy.

Special Features:

  • Made with a large squeaker for extra excitement.
  • Packed with fluff for mouthfuls of fun.
  • Crazy crinkle for a bite you can hear.
  • Made for dogs of all sizes.


Product Details:
Material: Polyester
Weight: 2.88 ounces
HxWxL: 7.5 x 3.7 x 3.6 inches

Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$11.99  Inc Tax
Jax & Bones Beach Ball Plush Dog Toy  - Large 5\
Jax & Bones Beach Ball Plush Dog Toy - Large 5" ('JB1681)
You can't beat a great day out at the beach, and the Jax & Bones Beach Ball delivers a ton of fun and then some!
This is a plush toy, available in a vibrant color and will keep your dog occupied from sunrise to sunset.
Jax & Bones products are cultivated from the highest quality material, always keeping your dog's safety in mind.

Special Features:
  • Made with soft ultra-plush fabric, perfect for cuddles.
  • Each toy is handcrafted with double stitched edges and reinforced for added durability so that they can stand up to everyday play.
  • Strong, loud, quality squeakers are included for hours of fun!

Care Instructions:
  • Machine washable.
  • Can be composted once completely unraveled.
  • *Dogs should always be supervised when playing with toys.*


Product Details:
Material: Polyester
Size: 5" Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$13.20  Inc Tax
Outward Hound Hide A Squirrel Plush Dog Puzzle Toy Brown  - Large
Outward Hound Hide A Squirrel Plush Dog Puzzle Toy Brown - Large ('OH31003)
Outward Hound's hide and seek plush dog puzzle was designed specifically to eliminate boredom, encourage positive play, and feed your dog's natural hunting instincts. 2-in-1 interactive play means double the fun with options to play fetch or hide and seek to keep your dog mentally-stimulated. For dogs who can't get enough of these plushy squirrels, check out our replacement 3-pack of Squeakin' Squirrels! Bound to become your curious canine's new favorite, our plush hide and seek line of puzzle toys are perfect for supervised fun of all sizes! Just remember to consider your dog's size and activity level when deciding which toy to get.

HIDE & SQUEAK FUN: The Hide A Squirrel dog puzzle is an easy way to get your furry friends engaged for hours of fun! Just fill the tree trunk with 3 stuffed squirrels, toss it, and let your dog's natural hunting instincts kick in!
2-IN-1 INTERACTIVE PLAY: Toss the squirrel-filled trunk, place it on the ground, or take the squeaky plush toys out and launch them for a game of fetch your dog is sure to love!
CHALLENGING & IRRESISTIBLE: Keep boredom at bay and you're curious canine mentally-stimulated while feeding their natural instincts to hunt with plush squeaky squirrels they won't be able to resist!
GENTLE ON THE TEETH AND GUMS: The (more...) Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$24.99  Inc Tax
KONG(R) Cozie(TM) Ali Alligator  - XL
KONG(R) Cozie(TM) Ali Alligator - XL ('KGZYX1)
The KONG Cozie(TM) Ali Alligator is a soft and luxuriously cuddly plush toy great for snuggle time comfort. Made with an extra layer of material for added strength, the KONG Cozie(TM) Ali Alligator is an ideal toy for softer chew sessions and indoor fun. The KONG Cozie(TM) Ali Alligator toy is sure to delight during snuggle and play time!

Special Features
  • Deluxe push for indoor snuggle time
  • Extra layer of material for added strength
  • Squeaker entices active play
  • Ideal for indoor fun
  • Adorable characters add to the fun

Product Details:
Weight: 7.3 ounces
HxWxL: 4.75 x 13.25 x 12.25 inches Thank you for shopping at Firstpetsupplies.com.com
$19.99  Inc Tax
Per Page      113 - 140 of 799

Categories